I made a religion
out of keeping you full.
Built an altar from my patience,
knelt at the mouth of your thirst,
and called it love
when you drank me like a sacrament.
I became fluent in the language of your wanting.
Learned which silences meant hunger,
which wounds required tending,
which parts of you
needed to be held a little more carefully.
I learned the geography of your emptiness,
the precise shape of every hollow place.
I could recognize your thirst
before you ever had to ask.
And God,
how faithfully I learned to pour.
I gave until generosity
became indistinguishable from emptiness.
Held my cup with bleeding hands,
careful not to let a single drop fall
from yours.
I made a virtue of going without.
Called my hunger discipline,
my exhaustion devotion,
my vanishing an act of grace.
Somewhere along the way,
I began to mistake the drought
for a test of faith.
But what becomes of a well
that gives without rain?
What becomes of the river
when every stream
has been taught to flow in only one direction?
Even the earth must eventually split
beneath the weight of its own thirst.
I think of the Danaids,
condemned to fill their vessels
for all eternity,
pouring water into vessels
that were never made to hold it.
Perhaps there is a particular cruelty
in loving something that can never be filled.
Perhaps the punishment
is not the pouring,
but the hope that, this time,
something might remain.
And still,
I kept returning to the well.
As though devotion were measured
by how much of myself
I could leave at the bottom.
I have mistaken my depletion
for proof of my love.
Mistaken being needed
for being cherished.
And perhaps the saddest thing
is that I do not remember
when I became so accustomed
to being thirsty.
I only remember
how instinctively I reached for you
whenever you were.
But now—
the altar is cold.
The river has receded.
There is no rain in the cistern,
no water left beneath the stone.
And still,
you hold out your cup.
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
142,483 Literary Works • 678,074 Reviews
Hello,
I hope you are doing well.
I came across your profile and wanted to reach out. I was wondering if you have any original stories, poems, or creative writing projects that you would be interested in bringing to life through custom artwork.
My name is Eve, and I am a professional commission-based artist specializing in comics, manga, webtoons, character illustrations, book covers, and visual storytelling.
I work with writers and authors to transform their written ideas, characters, and imaginative worlds into unique visual artwork while maintaining their original creative vision.
I offer custom paid artwork commissions and would love to discuss any ideas or projects you might be interested in visualizing.
If you are interested, feel free to reach me on Discord: **inksbyeve**.
Would you be open to exploring a creative collaboration?
Best regards,
Eve
Ahhh I loved this poem! It's so relatable, and your metaphor reminds me of my own experience with this exact situation.
You know that little smirk or smile you wear when reading certain pieces, not necessarily because you relate to everything being said, but because you recognise fragments of something familiar in them. There's a certain relief in encountering something that comes close to an experience or thought you've carried yourself. That's how I felt reading this.
Your poem is incredibly rich. I find the relationship between devotion and self-erasure particularly interesting. There's something unsettling about how you gradually turn your own depletion into a virtue, almost as though suffering becomes a measure of how much you love. I think the distinction between being needed and being cherished is especially important here.
I liked the recurring religious imagery, the altar, sacrament, and the idea of making a religion out of keeping someone full. It gives the piece an interesting dimension, because you become the sacrifice rather than the worshipper. (I'll bet you're Catholic.)
The reference to the Danaids was another rich addition, and a nice showcase of your versatility. I think it reinforces the futility of continuously pouring into something that can never be filled.
However, I do think some of the imagery occasionally becomes a little repetitive, especially towards the middle, where the ideas of thirst, drought, rivers and wells begin to reiterate an emotion the reader has already grasped. I'd be interested in seeing you trust some of your imagery a little more rather than always explaining what it represents. Ambiguity sometimes makes poems so intriguing to behold. Allow others the room to interpret, imagine and arrive at their own conclusions.
The ending, though, caught my attention. "And still, you hold out your cup." There's something unsettling about that final image. Even after everything has been exhausted, the expectation remains. I believe this is the strongest moment in the poem because your circumstances have changed, but the subject's behaviour hasn't.
And by now, I think you should know what needs to happen next. Yet that cup is still being held out. There's a whole other dimension to explore in that unresolved moment.
It's rich , Transitionally fluent, well put together, and Beautiful,
P.S it's not critcism, it's a thought, I mean where I pointed out some things.
Thanks
Thank you so much for taking the time to write all of this! I didn't expect a review this quick! I genuinely appreciate how thoughtfully you approached my poem, and it means a lot that you took the time to explore some of the ideas I was trying to convey, especially with a piece that's so personal to me.
Also you are so right about trusting my imagery and allowing more room for interpretation. That's something that I've never really thought of because I had always tried to make my writing packed with symbolism and metaphor to make it more interesting that i never really thought of doing anything like that. I'll definitely keep in mind moving forward!
Thank you again for being so kind and taking my work seriously. It honestly means more than you know! Also I am a Christian but I did grow up in a Catholic household lmao!
Get in! Lol, I had a feeling about the Catholic upbringing!
And you're very welcome. Honestly, I enjoy engaging with people's work, especially when there's something to unpack beyond the surface. I think symbolism and metaphors are wonderful tools (once they're in equilibrium), but sometimes what makes a poem intriguing is what the writer chooses not to tell us. There's beauty in leaving certain doors open and allowing readers to wander into them through their own experiences and interpretations.
Besides, I think writing is a continuous process of discovery. We're always finding new ways to express things, sometimes even discovering things we didn't know we were trying to say in the first place.
And I know it means a lot to you because I feel the same way whenever someone takes the time to review my work. That's why I pour my heart into engaging with each and every piece I read.
Keep writing, and I'll certainly be looking forward to reading more of your work!