Portrait of His Funeral (reviews please?)

by lilchoma

Published December 22, 2009

a soft slice of a shovel piercing the earth,
and the hollow thud as it falls
mercilessly
onto the colorless, joyless wooden box.
.
the wind, strong and capricious,
wrapping coats tighter
across shoulders,
throwing every color and length of hair
like willow leaves,
weeping sans tears.
.
unseen clouds, for all that care,
shade a cold world in an instant,
the next breaking, radiating
light and heat,
swimming through the cemetery,
and back beneath the clouds once again.
.
past the hum of the wind,
the soft monotony of human voice,
mumbling some symphony
of incoherent words, spilling sad farewells.
.
the final whisper of metal in earth
beckons the gathered
for one last longing glance,
ending with a listless turn away,
the silent sound of dress shoes
.
treading upon the vibrant, living grass,
plodding amongst the stone and marble
monuments of the dead.

Comments & reviews · 4
User avatar
Sabine
Review
Sabine wrote a review Review · Dec 29, 2009

absolutely gorgeous! concise and dreamy and melancholy. I especially liked this bit:
"ending with a listless turn away,
the silent sound of dress shoes
.
treading upon the vibrant, living grass,"

I really liked the touch of adding the specificity of 'dress shoes' for some reason. I think I might have one minor critique about this bit:

"throwing every color and length of hair
like willow leaves,"

I might have just left it as 'every length of hair' as this way feels a little too defined. But at the same time it's a really lovely simile.
Also, with the first line I really could hear that soft, damp earthly slice of the shovel.
I suppose, to sum up, it's all the sensory details that make this poem, clear without being over-wordy or too pointed. very nice job!

User avatar
iceprincess
Review
iceprincess wrote a review Review · Dec 27, 2009

For some reason, the poem is quite...apathetic? dull? I don't know, to be honest with you. It's like I'm seeing the scenes that you wrote though a murky looking-glass, and I just can't see it clearly.

Overall, your poem is quite good! Keep it up! :D

-Rosie =]

User avatar
R3b3L
Comment
R3b3L commented Comment · Dec 27, 2009

Your imagery is great.

I like your ending; I understand what you were saying.

I don't know why but this poem just feels kind of dull to me, but it's still good...

3/5

User avatar
EL FINITO
Comment
EL FINITO commented Comment · Dec 22, 2009

I enjoyed your poem the use of words were beautiful. But your last two stanza were confusing make it clear.



Every time I’ve gotten feedback that was hard to take it was usually hard to take because there was truth in it and I didn’t like that (or didn’t want to receive it). That’s not to say all harsh feedback is good or that we should be harsh for harshness’ sake, but learning to absorb truth without letting it break your inner core/break you is a lifelong skill that keeps your mind elastic and open to learning.
— soundofmind