Sparring help

by oddworks

Published November 17, 2026

12+

In Spar

PreviousNext

Before we start, I am well aware that this isn't perfect. This is a scene from early on in my novel, so far it's the first draft.

The setting itself is a tribe, that's inspired by pre Islamic Arabian/huns. The names aren't reflective of that yet tho.

I need help with the accuracy of 6-8th century swordfighting, and writing tips to fix this mess and make it readable for readers

For anyone that saw my other sort story I swear I have other characters, Alina isn't the same person. In "where?" It was a placeholder.

Typos and tenses will be fixed in revision, I don't need help with that. Just the clarity and accuracy

***

The two happened across the sparring fences.

Despite being almost empty, Scarlet turned towards Alina, excitement written on her face.

"Al-"

"I can't, Althy promised me not o do anything stupid."

"It's a spar."

"Remember the last time?"

Scarlet looked up, in mock thought.

Alina snapped her fingers.

"You do."

"You mean when I said that lulkhym was-"

"Don't."

Scarlet started laughing.

"Why were you so defens-"

"It is a cultural mark and i-"

"Whatever, if you don't want Althea to drag us back I'd suggest we just head in there."

Scarlet gestured to the sparring field, her voice going quieter in the last three words.

Alina clicked her tongue,

Then she approached the gate.

"Get in then."

"Gladly."

Alina waved over a keeper for the key.

As they were heading in, Scarlet dismissed the offered wooden weapons before she joined her.

Alina scowled and blocked her eyes from the sun.

She should have picked a better spot.

She moved herself behind the rays.

"Really?"

Scarlet shielded her eyes.

"You wanted to come here."

Both Scarlet and Alina stood facing each other.

"What's the count?"

Scarlet unsheathed her sword.

The blade was [design her blade and research].

"We had a count?"

Alina's hand inched towards her own.

Scarlet threw something at the bell.

Alina couldn't see what it was before scarlet lunged at her.

Alina bent down, aiming for one of Scarlets legs.

Scarlet quickly deflected her blow and fell back before Alina could retaliate.

Alina was towering over her now.

She raised her sword.

Scarlets foot hooked around Alinas ankle and made her fall.

Alina wiped off the blood on her lip before a sword laid on her neck.

"Strike."

"Go to hell."

Scarlet pulled out a cloth.

"I'm fine."

Alina muttered.

She got up.

"How many strikes?"

"Usual."

"Gods-"

Scarlet lunged at her again.

"Hold up, that completely-"

Alina couldn't finish her sentence as she started deflecting her strikes.

She did however, see an opening on her side.

Scarlet paused as Alinas sword pricked at her side.

"Strike one."

Alina said, copying Scarlets tone.

"Alright, alright."

They went back to their sides of the field.

"That's what you get for cheat-"

"Shut up."

As the sun reached evening and [describe the evening sun], poets began gathering near the square.

Alina tuned out most of them, aiming her sword towards her chest.

"Strike three."

Scarlet groaned.

"Break?"

Alina stared at Scarlet, her sweat shining on her face.

"Eh, you can go if you want."

She reached for her own cloth to wipe her forehead with.

"I was asking for you."

Scarlet stood, wiping the dust off of her.

Alina waved her off.

"Of course."

Alina was opposite of scarlet now.

Their eyes stayed locked.

Alina crouched lightly, blocking the noises of the market.

For one moment only a small part of the world mattered.

Scarlet's own sword, which was usually restless was shaking from her own contained laughter.

She went first, her blade swinging in a feint.

Alina attacked.

Her sword laid on Scarlet's.

Alinas eyes glanced up at her neck.

If she "failed" she can go for the stomach.

She turned her hand upwards.

Scarlet glanced down.

Good.

Alina struck at it.

It hit against against Scarlet's before deflecting down to her stomach.

Scarlet cut away.

They began pacing.

Alina remained low.

Scarlet was against the fence now.

Beside them poets were now at the stands, under the shades.

She notes one hired by the Qayam house.

Alina made the mistake of glancing at him before scarlet attacked again.

She parried it before falling back.

Scarlet was approaching her now. Alina pulled herself up by the fence gate and hooked the blade in Scarlets hilt.

Her eyes glanced towards the poets again.

Her breathing quickened as she saw Dāniyāl.

His voice-

She felt her hand twist as she was knocked back.

To add insult to injury, Scarlet took Alinas sword as well and held both to her neck.

"What happened? You-"

She looked at where Dāniyāl was.

Scarlet raised an eyebrow before looking down at Alina.

"It's not that-"

"The Count?"

"He's hardly a count yet."

Comments & reviews · 4
User avatar
KHart101
Review
KHart101 wrote a review Review · Nov 18

I'm did some research when i found this, and blades during the time period you are asking for commonly were long and straight, no real fancy curves like you commonly see in books or movies. There would be a shallow fuller (dip along the center of the blade) or there wouldn't be on at all. The handle would be thin and wrapped in a simple leather, probably worn at the edges from use. The blade wouldn't have much extra detain, and would look pretty plain. The guard and hilt would be, once again, a simple design that is designed with functionality in mind. For the feel of the blade, it would be more tip heavy, better for slashing and making wider cuts than intricate moves. She wouldn't be doing much intricate footwork, and her attacks would be simple, axe like swings.
For the evening sun, that will depend on your planets atmosphere. If it is more sulfuric, with more volcanoes erupting in the vicinity, the evening sky and sunsets will be a more vibrant ornage and red, however, more pollution can dull and mute the colours.
I really like your scene so far, I hope you find the right information and format for it!

User avatar
Snoink
Review
Snoink wrote a review Review · Nov 18

Oh, hello! :)

Since it doesn't really seem like you want any grammar stuff, I'll dive right into the story!

While I am no expert on swords, a quick Google search told me that the sort of swords that they used in 6-8th century in pre-Islamic/early Islamic culture were straight, doubled edge swords that were carried on the back in a baldric! So I'll just approach it with that in mind...

The two happened across the sparring fences.

Despite being almost empty, Scarlet turned towards Alina, excitement written on her face.

"Al-"

"I can't, Althy promised me not o do anything stupid."

"It's a spar."

"Remember the last time?"


Okay, so a couple of things...

You have in this story there's sparring fences... and they can hear the sound of the marketplace. So I have to ask... why is there a random sparring place right next to a market? Like... markets are too crowded for any real planned sparring match. So wouldn't they be walking somewhere like an army base or something? Especially since they were offered wooden weapons BEFORE they started sparring, which kind of indicates that this was a place that was deliberately made just for sparring matches.

If this is true... then why would Scarlet and Alina actually... be just passing by casually? It sounds from the scene that Alina doesn't have any intention on battling, and Scarlett pressures her into it. But like... wouldn't Alina realize, "Oh no, Scarlet is walking toward the sparring grounds... again. Let's just avoid it." So I think the argument would start a lot sooner.

Also... if Alina doesn't know that they are going to spar... why does she have her sword??? Like, it doesn't sound like she is in a war zone. So why would you just randomly have a walk with a sword strapped on your back??? Like. That's kind of the equivalent of having a shotgun strapped to your back -- very noticeable. You wouldn't do that unless you were planning something. If you wanted something for protection, you probably would choose something that can be concealed -- maybe a dagger?

Also, if she's not expecting a spar, she's probably not armored up at all. (Nor did the fight scene have any indications of them wearing any armor or even helets. Which means...

As they were heading in, Scarlet dismissed the offered wooden weapons before she joined her.


So... um...

1) They are presumably not wearing armor.
2) Scarlet just dismissed the wooden weapons for sparring.

WHICH MEANS THEY ARE USING ACTUAL BLADES. WITHOUT ARMOR.

This is actually deadly??? I don't understand why they are doing this. I don't understand why Alina is like, "Oh, okay. This is cool." Like. If they make ANY mistake, they have a good chance at either permanently maiming each other or killing each other, and they're just so... nonchalant about it. Especially after THIS beginning...

Both Scarlet and Alina stood facing each other.

"What's the count?"

Scarlet unsheathed her sword.

The blade was [design her blade and research].

"We had a count?"

Alina's hand inched towards her own.

Scarlet threw something at the bell.

Alina couldn't see what it was before scarlet lunged at her.


Like. Scarlet doesn't even really give her a chance. Alina wants to start it with a count, Scarlet kind of starts it on her own and charges before Alina can really register?? Like, okay Alina kind of expected it, but UGH WHY.

And why are they putting double-edged blades on each other's NECKS? I realize it's a sparring match, but DUDE. THEY DON'T HAVE ARMOR. Why wouldn't they change the rules and adjust it for this reality? Otherwise, someone's going to get really hurt. And the medical advancements back then weren't very great.

Anyway, this whole thing is just... a lot. So in your next draft, I would probably...

- Make Scarlet convince Alina to go sparring with actual blades beforehand, since it seems wild that they just happen to go to the sparring match with real blades as a coincidence.

- Have them wear their armor and helmets if they're using real blades!!!

- If they aren't going to wear their armor, consider having Alina step up and insist on the wooden blades anyway. Because honestly this whole thing is insane.

- If you want them to fight with their real swords unarmored... make it part of their internal monologue. They know this is dangerous. Why are they doing it? Do they trust each other so much it's inconsequential to them? Is there any point where one of them is like, "Omg, I almost just DIED." And this kind of sobers them up? Are they just excitable maniacs who like the thrill of danger? Like, describe all this! Right now, from afar, I have no idea why they're doing all of this. At least describe it enough internally where I can understand where the character is coming from!

Anyway, just some thoughts from me. Good luck fleshing this story out into something incredible!

oddworks replied · Nov 18

Hey, I just realized reading your review how crazy it seems like without any context, and I really should have clarified it.
Basically, a few generations back, the empire was torn apart by monsters appearing due to a bunch of divine issues.
So currently, it's a military based culture.

And yeah, these two have no concept of self awareness, the other characters even bring this up. But they tend to roughouse since due to being soldiers against incomprehensible Eldritch horrors, they've been through worst than a minor stab wound. (Again, they have armour). So because of their career, they have a massive amount of trust in each other, since they basically grew up together and know their limits and when to stop. But even then it's not exactly healthy. And they have magic (as limited as it can be) and healing to help if they got injured.

Due to the culture, the both have armour and swords just because.
Both for nobility to show off their status and for self defense.
Theres a section nearby the market for sparring.

It's less so of a market, and more so of a towns square, since sparring and fighting from an early age is normalized in the setting.
Again, I should have clarified that it's more of a town square rather than call it a marketplace.

But yeah, Alina was kind of an idiot for not noticing them walking towards the sparring fences😭 that's my bad.

Let me know if there's any concerns I missed!
Cheers,
Oddworks

Snoink replied · Nov 18

Ahhhh, I see! So, the trick is to fold all this information into the story organically. Which is NOT easy to do. But like, if she sees the sword coming and thinks, "If she hits me, this is going to take more than just one healing potion" that might help explain things. Or if she is squinting in the sunlight (like you already have!) and her friend's armor is just... gleaming to the point where she is having even more trouble, she can think that. So you kind of have to sneak in these details in your description so that the world truly comes alive. :)

oddworks replied · Nov 19

Thanks man

User avatar
Tikaya
Review
Tikaya wrote a review Review · Nov 18

So you were talking about fight scenes, let’s see what you got 😊

Right of the bat I can already tell that something’s off with the paragraphing. Even in the most action-packed fight scene where you want short, punchy sentences in short, punchy paragraphs to suggest things going down very quickly, even in THOSE, you usually have longer paragraphs of necessary descriptions in between.

I have no idea about sword fighting, just about scene flow so that’s what I’ll be focusing on.

Generally unless you want something very specific, I’d advise against posting first drafts. Typos etc make it super hard to judge the story fairly and I always get distracted when I encounter them.

Yep, I think the most important thing you need to focus on is the in between descriptions. Your story is very barebones, I don’t really have a feel for where the fight takes place, what the floor’s made off, if there are things in the arena, what type of clothes the MCs wear…

Scarlet threw something at the bell.
What does that mean??? You might want to either have this already in previous chapters or explain it here o_o

Alina bent down, aiming for one of Scarlets legs.
I feel like here the info that she does strike with her weapon is missing.

Is Scarlet falling back, on her behind, or taking a few steps back? I would advise to describe impact. I have the hardest time keeping track in who’s head we are. So I kinda wish you would focus more on how it feels to deflect a blow or land on your back. Right now, you’re just describing action. But action without stakes or ~emotional responses~ is just … boring.

Scarlets foot hooked around Alinas ankle and made her fall.
like f.e. here. Why did Alina not notice that? Make the moves the characters pull off responsive. Why did Scarlet manage to draw her down to her level with that? Was it the surprise? Is she stronger than Alina? Show that!

Same goes here:
Alina wiped off the blood on her lip
Why is she injured? I mean I get it’s probably from the fall but you didn’t describe how she lands, so she might have just spontaneously started getting a nosebleed due to allergies or something.

Alina couldn't finish her sentence as she started deflecting her strikes.
What kind of strikes? What does that look like?

She parried it before falling back.
What is it? How does that look like? (I am repeating myself because you don’t really describe what the characters… look like when they do ~thing~
In general, I wish you also would focus more on the physical exhaustion, how they’re sweating etc, they’ve been at this for an almost unrealistic amount of time after all. Have the weapons grown heavy in their hands yet? Show the TOLL this takes.

As someone who writes fight scenes and enjoys them very much, I might not be able to tell you much about sword fighting techniques but I can tell you that this is very much a first draft XD So yeah, descriptions are lacking everywhere.

I would also agree with your other review: some inner monologue from whoever’s head we are in (I..think it’s Alina’s?) to show how she judges her opponent, maybe reminiscing how her opponent usually fights etc and if they are switching things up or remain predictable. That’s what makes fight scenes fun. Not just describing what’s happening.


Image

oddworks replied · Nov 18

Honestly, yeah, reading your review it is pretty bare.
That's what's missing.
All on all I'll keep that in mind.
But basically
Environment
The toll on characters
Emphasize Alina's pov more
Their clothing
Shorter punchier sentences
Clarify that Scarlet got her down by surprise

Please let me know if I missed anything, thanks for taking the time to read this
All the best

HellsLocalResident wrote a review Review · Nov 18

Listen, I'm not a historian nor do I know anything about Islamic swordfighting techniques, but from my experience, fight scenes are the hardest to write because of how much they rely on the author's ability to write choreography. From what I gather, this scene moves way too quickly and if that is in fact a bug and not a feature-- that might be a good thing if you're considering the advice I'm about to give. Instead of focusing too much effort into choreographing the fight itself, focus instead on the character's internal monologue, what are they thinking during the fight? Are they analyzing their opponent's moves? Are they planning their next moves or is there mind somewhere else?

In addition to that, what do they look like? what are they doing? how are they utilizing their surroundings in battle? What expressions are they making?

like here:

Alina bent down, aiming for one of Scarlets legs.

Scarlet quickly deflected her blow and fell back before Alina could retaliate.

Alina was towering over her now.

She raised her sword.

Scarlets foot hooked around Alinas ankle and made her fall.

Alina wiped off the blood on her lip before a sword laid on her neck.

"Strike."

"Go to hell."

Scarlet pulled out a cloth.

"I'm fine."

Alina muttered.

She got up.

"How many strikes?"

"Usual."

"Gods-"

this would be a great place for a description or monologue-- like maybe Scarlet is making a smug expression and Alina is really annoyed by it. Descriptions are really good at adding flavor and flow to a fight scene, usually enough to negate the need for extensive choreography in the first place. But of course, if you *Want* to include it, be my guest. But remember that no matter how much you study the fighting styles, it wont translate to the reader without being properly described and even if you describe in detail, that might get boring so do add something else as well.

oddworks replied · Nov 18

Thanks, I'll edit it in my actual draft, that might be useful.
Sorry for the short reply, I just woke up. But yeah I'll keep that in mind



The only fool bigger than the person who knows it all is the person who argues with him.
— Stanislaw Jerszy Lec