Yesteryear, I was here
In this very place
But oh! How much has changed
Except all that eyes can see.
For in this deathless matter
What change may overcome
The sickness of stillness
When it sees the visage
Of man's desiring dreams.
Oh indeed, what a mystery
Is matter's stillness to me.
"Thy brain commutes to be
In places far from dusty rocks
To live in worlds of mystery.
Thy mind a boundless house
Of presence never before seen
But who may see this fantasy
When he is blind in misery?"
Said who to who I cannot know
But it was all within me
From far, far beyond me.
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hiya! Today i'm going to do my own personal review style called The Rose method (trademark pending)
Rose:
For in this deathless matter
What change may overcome
This line was incredible i was a nice hook and kept the reader excited to keep going
Thorn:
this may just be me being super nitpicky, but i didn't like the fact that mystery was used twice and so close together nonetheless
Bud: due to this being a poem the climax is hard to identify.
Stem: the most interesting part was the : "Thy brain commutes to be
In places far from dusty rocks
To live in worlds of mystery.
Thy mind a boundless house
Of presence never before seen
But who may see this fantasy
When he is blind in misery?"
this line, it gave us such a nice area to read also it was spaced out nicely so it was easy to read in the place
Soil: A connection i've made is that....I don't really have a connection to this story
👌👍👏👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Yo, Riyas here to review!
Man, the category you put this in—"Bad and better-than-bad poetry"—is honestly hilarious, but you're selling yourself short because this is actually a really deep and thought-provoking piece!
I love the philosophical vibe you've got going on here. The opening is super strong: "Yesteryear, I was here / In this very place / But oh! How much has changed / Except all that eyes can see." That immediately sets up this feeling of being in a familiar place but feeling completely different inside. It's a really relatable human experience.
The imagery you use to describe the mind and the brain is where this poem really shines. "Thy brain commutes to be / In places far from dusty rocks / To live in worlds of mystery" is a super cool way to describe daydreaming or escaping reality. And "Thy mind a boundless house / Of presence never before seen" is genuinely beautiful writing. It feels like the narrator is trapped in their body while their mind is off exploring the universe.
A couple of tiny tips to make it even better:
The line "In this deathless matter" is a bit abstract. I get that it's about feeling stuck in a lifeless environment, but it took me a second read to understand exactly what you meant. Also, watch out for some phrasing like "Of man's desiring dreams"—it reads a little bit like older, classic poetry, which is cool, but it slightly clashes with the more modern tone of "Oh indeed, what a mystery." If you want it to feel more natural, maybe try something like "Of what a man desires."
Overall, this is a really nice meditation on the difference between what we see with our eyes and what we experience in our minds. It’s got a quiet, mysterious energy to it. Keep writing, this was a great read! 🖤
Thank you so very much for the review!!! It's really encouraging, as well as the feedback on what to improve. Thanks a lot!!