Published November 20, 2026
Warning: This work has been rated 16+ for violence.
*These fanfic chapters are under my folder “Creepypasta stuff”. Gacha Club character designs are under this forum: https://www.writerfeed.com/topic/117842-my-character-designs-lt-33-3?start=420. Enjoy!*
Chapter Seven
Isaac finally steers the ship towards a cat standing on a tiny island, meowing back at us. It jumps onto the ship and doesn’t get off.
On the island is a brown treasure chest, glittering with dablons and gemstones. Isaac has stopped steering and turns to me, his toothy smile reaching up to his eyes.
“The enemy dared to hide the treasure and now walks our ship! Grab it and make it walk the plank fast!”
The ocean is rocking us up and down! It’s starting to look too much like dirt and Isaac isn’t even holding the wheel anymore. He’s glaring at me. He’s mad at me.
“Well, do your duty! Don’t be a useless worm!”
Useless worm. Isaac’s Mom calls him that. His voice sounds too mean, just like how a real pirate would sound. The ocean scene I had worked so hard to make is melting away too fast. I can already see the outline of dead plants in Isaac’s backyard.
I stretch my arm out towards the cat. My arm can stretch reallyyyy long, since I have no bones.
When I hold the cat, I squeeze. The rest of the pirate world is gone. We’re in his backyard now.
Chapter Eight
It looks like it’s in pain..it keeps struggling…maybe I should stop…
…But Isaac doesn’t want me to stop. I can tell…
I’m scared. It’s just wiggling and I think that it’s crying. Is it crying? Can cats cry? No, they’re animals. They don’t have feelings.
POP!
It explodes and makes a popping sound like how I make when I jump out of my box.
Oh my gosh…that’s…icky…what is it called? Is it…blood? Oh my...there’s blood everywhere…it’s my own fault..I killed it…I’m a big, mean monster…Isaac is crying…no…he’s…laughing?
I turn around to look at Isaac, who is holding his stomach and rolling all over the floor. He’s laughing. He thinks that this is funny.
I don’t really think that it’s funny, but I laugh anyway.
If Isaac thinks that this is funny, then I must think that it’s funny too, right? That’s what friends do.
Chapter Nine
Isaac has run with the cat. He’s going to throw it behind a bush so no one finds it.
I’m sitting on the grass. I didn’t really laugh with Isaac, I was only pretending to.
My hands still have blood all over them. I tried making the blood go away, but it stayed.
I wish it were gone.
End of chapter
Continue to next chapter Jason joins a carnivalPoints:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
These chapters connect to this:
“You can’t save everybody, Jack”. (Intro-Chapter Three)
“You can’t save everybody, Jack” (Chapter Four-Chapter Six)
Hia it is me again. I read the other 2 uploads from this series so I shall continue reading it =D
Okay that was chilling to read. It makes Isaac out as the corrupting influence and I’m suddenly feeling so sad for LJ’s sake. (Also poor cat…)I kinda wish there was more than just “oh yeah, cat, it joins us without leaving” from LJ. What does he feel about the cat? And if he feels nothing, doesn’t he at least wonder why Isaac cares so much about it? Just… some sort of comment on what’s happening from our window into the story would be nice. Or more a… an explanation on why we stop to pick up a cat when the narration doesn’t seem to be very interested in it… Some more descriptions maybe to settle all the readers back in the scene? =D
I do like that Isaac immediately declares the cat an enemy and how that bleeds into reality. That part is really well handled. It’s probably the lack of gravitas with which the cat’s boarding of the ship is treated that is bothering me. Everything else in Ch7 is haunting and I like how you describe the worsening relationship between Isaac and LJ. And, as I said, how reality is bleeding into the illusion!
I love how he draws this comparison. Not only bc he doesn’t really have many experiences to compare in the first place but also because it creates a parallel between himself and the cat, both being manipulated by other ppl.. until they snap…
Ahhh that characterisation is so well done!!!
CH9
I really like that last chapter as a reflection on all that came before. Aww man, now I feel bad for the monster, as intended.
Thanks for sharing!
You’re welcome! This is what happens in the original story, but I wanted to describe what LJ thought about it more and I also added in the pirate/ocean illusion. Thank you for reading and your advice.
I think you could do even more with that :) Like, dig even deeper into LJ's thoughts. I really like your take on the story (tho I do not know the original. I will be forever biased in this, your LJ is the LJ for me =D)
The original is good too but I find it a bit excessively gory. I’m so glad you like my interpretation of him! ^v^